VPN vs Proxy vs Tor and Which One Fits the Job
A reader wrote to me in September after cancelling his VPN subscription. He had found a free proxy list, set one in his browser, and could reach a site that had been blocked at his university.

A reader wrote to me in September after cancelling his VPN subscription. He had found a free proxy list, set one in his browser, and could reach a site that had been blocked at his university. Two weeks later his email account was accessed from a country he has never visited. The proxy was almost certainly the reason, and he had no way to prove it either way, which is the usual outcome.
These three tools get discussed as if they were competing products at different prices. They are not. They move different amounts of your traffic, through different numbers of hands, with different things written down along the way. Picking between them by cost is how people end up with the free option that reads their mail. What follows is the version I give friends, built around what you are actually trying to do rather than which one is best.
What each one actually moves
A VPN takes everything your device sends, wraps it in encryption, and hands it to one server you have a contract with. Your network provider sees that you connected to that server and nothing about what you did. The site you visit sees the server's address. One company, the VPN provider, can see both ends if it chooses to look, which is why the wording of its logging policy is the whole product.
A proxy relays requests for one application, usually a browser, and usually without encryption unless it is specifically an HTTPS or SOCKS5 proxy with TLS. Your other apps keep going out directly. The proxy operator sees the sites you ask for, and with a plain HTTP proxy can read and modify anything not already encrypted. Free public proxies are run by people whose motivation you cannot inspect, and a working free proxy that stays up for months is a business with a revenue model you have not been told about.
Tor sends your traffic through three volunteer relays chosen fresh for each circuit, with layered encryption, so no single relay knows both who you are and where you are going. Nobody is paying for it and nobody can be subpoenaed into revealing a full path, because no relay holds the full path. In exchange you get the slowest connection of the three and a browser that deliberately makes itself look identical to every other Tor browser.
The practical differences side by side
Figures below are from my own testing on a 200 Mbps home line in October, measured over a week rather than from one run, because single speed tests on any of these are close to meaningless.
| VPN | Browser proxy | Tor | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Covers | Whole device | One app | Tor Browser only |
| Encrypted | Yes, to the server | Often not | Yes, three layers |
| Typical speed kept | 70 to 92 percent | Varies wildly | 2 to 10 Mbps |
| Added latency | 8 to 40 ms nearby | 20 to 300 ms | 300 ms to 2 seconds |
| Who could log you | The provider | The operator | No single relay |
| Cost | About 3 to 12 dollars a month | Free or cheap | Free |
| Streaming | Sometimes works | Rarely | Effectively never |
The latency column explains more about daily use than the speed column. Video calls, online games and anything interactive break on jitter, not on bandwidth. Tor at 400 ms is fine for reading and unusable for a meeting. More on where the loss comes from sits in the notes on how much a VPN slows a connection.
Tor is not a free VPN
The advice that annoys me most is the suggestion that anyone who does not want to pay should just use Tor. It sounds generous. It is wrong in both directions, and it gets people into trouble.
Tor protects the link between you and the site from anyone watching the network. It does nothing about what you tell the site once you arrive. Log into an account over Tor and that account knows exactly who you are, so the privacy you bought by accepting two second page loads has been handed straight back. Worse, logging in from a constantly shifting exit address is the single most reliable way to get an account flagged, locked, or hit with a verification loop. The reader I mentioned at the top was using a proxy, not Tor, but the account lockout pattern is identical.
In the other direction, a VPN is not a weaker Tor. For the specific job of hiding your traffic from the cafe network, your landlord's router or your mobile carrier, a VPN does the whole job at full speed, and the three relay design buys you nothing you needed. Tor is built for a threat model where the person you are hiding from can watch large parts of the network and compel companies to hand over records. Most people's actual problem is a hotel Wi-Fi and a nosy internet provider.
There is also a quieter cost. Tor exit addresses are published, so a large share of the web treats them as hostile. Expect endless image puzzles, blocked shopping carts and banks that refuse outright. Some sites simply return an error with no explanation.
Pick by task, not by tool
Public Wi-Fi in an airport or cafe. VPN, every time, with the kill switch on. It covers your mail client and your banking app, not just the browser tab you remembered.
Reaching a site blocked by your office or campus network. A VPN if it is allowed, and a proxy only if you accept that the operator sees the request. Never put credentials through a free proxy.
Checking a price or a catalogue as it appears in another country. A VPN, or a proxy if it is only a browser check and nothing sensitive. This is the one honest use for a cheap proxy, and the piece on choosing a server location covers which city to pick.
Streaming a service you pay for while travelling. VPN, and expect to try several servers. Detection is constant, and no tool wins this permanently.
Researching something you would not want tied to your name. Tor Browser, with no logins, no downloads opened outside the browser, and default settings left alone. Changing the window size or adding extensions makes you more identifiable, not less.
Reporting something sensitive or working under a government that watches the network. Tor, and a conversation with someone who does this professionally. This is past the point where a blog post should be your source.
Stacking them is usually pointless
Running Tor through a VPN is popular advice and it helps in exactly two situations: your network provider blocks or flags Tor connections, or you do not want your provider to record that you used it. In those cases, connect the VPN first and then open Tor Browser. The order matters and the other order, Tor then VPN, breaks the design and should be left alone unless you know precisely why you want it.
What it does not do is make you more anonymous. The anonymity still comes from the three relays, and the VPN provider now knows you use Tor. Speed drops again, often to the point where pages time out. I tested it for a week and gave up on anything beyond text.
Chaining proxies behind a VPN is worse than useless, since each extra hop adds latency and another operator who can see the traffic. If a guide tells you to stack four proxies, close it.
What to check this week
If you are using any proxy you did not pay for, stop using it for anything involving a login, and check the recent activity list on your email account while you are at it. That takes five minutes and is the highest value thing in this article.
If you already pay for a VPN, open its settings and confirm two things: the protocol in use and whether the kill switch is actually on. Many apps ship with a legacy protocol selected, and the differences are set out in the notes on which VPN protocol to pick.
And if you have never opened Tor Browser, download it once and read a few pages. Feeling how slow it is tells you more about where it belongs than any comparison table, including mine.
FAQ
Is Tor safer than a VPN?
Against a network level observer, yes, because no single party sees both ends. Against the sites you log into, neither helps, since your account identifies you regardless.
Can I use a free proxy safely?
Only for reading pages you would be happy to post publicly. The operator can see every request and, on an unencrypted proxy, alter the page you get back.
Does a VPN hide my traffic from my internet provider?
It hides the contents and destinations. Your provider still sees that you hold an encrypted connection to one address, and how much data moved through it.
Why do websites block Tor but not VPNs?
Tor exit addresses are published in a public list, so blocking them is trivial. VPN addresses are harder to enumerate, though streaming services do a reasonable job of it.
More in VPN Basics
VPN Basics
How to Run a VPN Leak Test for DNS, IP and WebRTC
A VPN app can show a green shield and the word "Connected" while your laptop quietly sends every website lookup to your...
VPN Basics
How to Choose a VPN Server Location for Each Task
You open the VPN app and it offers you 94 countries, a "fastest server" button and a map with glowing dots.
VPN Basics
VPN No Logs Policy and What It Actually Promises
Nearly every VPN provider promises it keeps no logs, and the claim is printed so large on their homepages that it starts to...